I haven't reviewed any products from this brand even though I have quite a good number of items from them. But I think I've finally used whatever I have enough to make a comprehensive review on them.
I will start of with the eye quads, because these were the things that I bought from Majolica.
Majolica Majorca Eye Quads
PK 383 Pink, BL 381 Blue, GD 886 Gold. See how MM codes their palette in a recognisable way? PK for pink... ...
Available: Most Watsons
Volume: 4g
Star Properties: Gradient colours. Made in Japan (really? oh wow!)
The Gold One
This is the one that I had difficulty using at first, because it is hard to find browns that suit my skin. Browns always make me look like I have extra dark eye circles, and sometimes muddy. So as you can see, I didn't touch much, mostly used only the 3rd brown on the bottom left.
The Blue One
This is a palette that is way too light for my skin tone. And the deepest blue in the bottom right is way too dark!!
I bought this because my very first blue palette was really bad, and I thought it is because of the price, since I got this brand called In2it, that is so cheap at $14. Majolica is way up, at around $30.
But I was quite wrong. Blue just doesn't seems to work for me. And I even went on to get a Kate palette just to confirm that I really can't work with blue.
The Pink One
haha, judging from the sponge tip applicator and the markings on this palette, can tell that this is most go-to palette. In fact, this has been sitting in the eye palette pocket of my Essentials Pouch ever since I got it, which is around 2 years already.
It seems that a good number of people are not fond of wearing pink because it supposedly makes people look like they just cried overnight. And I also heard from Youtubers that Asian eyes that, especially those so-called hooded ones, like mine (which is actually called Tapered Double Eyelids), shouldn't wear pink. As pink really makes the more fleshy hooded eyes look even more swollen as compared to say, those with deep set eyes (which normally looks more boney due to more prominent brow bones).
But, I think makeup is a really personal affair, and I've never gotten sarcastic remarks about how I look like I cried whenever I this. In fact, I always get compliments when I wear pink! It is more the green shade that I feel makes me look like a witch from Wicked.
So yes to pink palettes!
Swatches:
The Pink One
All the Majolica's eye shadows are very sheer in my opinion. I think it's the same case with Shu Uemura too, because they are reportedly from the same company.
But in a general sense, Japanese colours are on the sheer side, and Western ones tend to go on the stage-makeup heavy side.
My favourite colour here is really the 3rd pink. I tend to use it for other looks, not necessarily with the whole palette.
The Blue One
See how light that second colour is? It is almost a white, and never fits in my crease. It makes my entire eyes look like they pop out, with no definition. And the dark blue is not at all a lashline colour. (In MM's palettes, the darkest shade is supposed to be used as eyeliner.)
The Gold One
I am very fond of the 2nd shade in the gold palette, because it is a good highlighter shade for my skin, with that pale yellow. It's really my go-to highlighter because the pale yellow matches pretty much any other colour scheme. I can actually use the pink palette, but top it off using pale yellow to tone down on the pink-ness.
In general, MM's palettes are really great for highlighter colours, because the amount of glitter is wonderful. If you're doing a black smokey eye, and want to up the game with glitter, I highly recommend just swiping a little of any MM colour, can be the dark brown for neutral smokey, dark pink for sultry, dark blue for a starry starry night feel. These are really super glamourous if paired nicely.
I hate the dark brown here though. Really muddy colour for me.
Staying Power
Now, we've reach the point that I have big gripe with.
All the swatches were done using a lot of powder. I really tried my best to pile on and on so that it appears in the photos.
I am sorry about the background.
But my major gripe is that, ALL MM eye colours never stay for long!!!
All I did was use my other hand to rub. And it's really all gone.
Can you imagine what it was like to use these back in the days that Singapore didn't have Sephora??
Sephora was a dream come true because it brought us two all-time best eye bases, like the
Urban Decay Primer Potion, and Too Faced Shadow Insurance. Before UDPP became famous, L'oreal and Maybelline never had eye bases. I believe NYX doesn't too. Not sure about MAC, but MAC is not famous for eye bases at all.
And it was really UDPP that helped me get these MM Palettes back on track. Or else, I'd probably think they are all useless and waste of money and try others. But no, now, I am still using them, because UDPP helps the shadows to stick on for longer.
I used to bring out the palette in my makeup pouch so that I can touch up in 3-4 hours time. LOL, now you understand why I said the pink one has been sitting in my makeup pouch for the longest time. =P
Cost
I do think these are costly. But really, 4 years ago, MM was arguably the best you can get in a drugstore (at least they are made in Japan). That was the time Watsons and Guardian only carried L'oreal, Maybelline, Revlon, ZA, and SilkyGirl. No such thing as Rimmel, Canmake, Cezanne, Gosh, LaSplash, Bourjois, and DollyWink.
And Sasa was not as well stocked as now, with Cyber Colours, iNuovi, and theBalm.
Nowadays, if you ask me what can be bought with the same budget as for MM, I'd point you to Sasa, because that's really where all the mid-tier products are, meaning, products that have the quality of counter brands, and that bit more expensive than drugstore, yet much more payoff than drugstore. Personally, I don't like Revlon/Maybelline palettes. L'oreal's are slightly better. And I can't stand ZA. Silkygirl is starting to get overpriced.
Majolica Majorca is still like the Queen in Watsons because of their vanity table booth, and really high pricing for drugstore, with a single blush costing $25. And MM seldom have discounts.
My Verdict: Okay Nice 3/5.
If you don't have it, don't have to get it. If you have it, like me, then it might be good to take it out again and rediscover its use, when paired with other brands.
The sheerness is not for me. Neither is the over-glitter. The last dark shade is too dark, while the rest too light. Great for highlighter. I like to use the 3rd shade with other eyeshadows.
How about you? MM was the raved brand in that time, so have you got any of their products out of curiosity? If yes, are you still using them? Which would you recommend, and which would you not?